Beef cattle
2.6 million cattle were
killed for meat in the UK
in 2008.1 Cattle raised for meat come from two sources,
either from animals bred specifically to produce calves for meat production, or
the surplus calves created by the dairy industry. It is estimated that around 50% of UK
beef is produced from surplus dairy calves.2
Milk producing cows are made
to produce a calf every year, in order to keep their milk production levels
high enough to be profitable. Some of
the female calves will be kept as replacement milk cows, but the question of
how to dispose of the remainder is currently a major issue for the
industry. In the past many calves would
be exported for veal, usually to be raised in systems which have been banned in
the UK
on animal welfare grounds. Only a small
number of calves are now exported from the UK, partly due to an export ban due
to fears over bovine TB and also demand being much lower than previously after the
lifting of the BSE-era export ban in 2006.3
As dairy cattle are bred to
produce high milk yields rather than meat, purebred dairy calves are sometimes
considered too scrawny to be worth raising for meat. Calves considered ‘useless’ are likely to be
shot at birth. Between June 2008 and May
2009 an estimated 118,000 male dairy calves were killed shortly after birth.3
The dairy industry,
encouraged by supermarkets, is currently looking at ways to get more dairy
calves raised and killed for meat within the UK meat industry. 3 Several animal welfare groups are currently proposing
that the answer to the dairy industry’s problem of surplus calves is to
encourage consumers to eat British veal.3
The milk industry is therefore supplying the meat industry with a
significant proportion of its raw materials.
Some pure bred beef cattle
are being bred to be so muscular (and therefore ‘produce’ more meat) that the
breeding cows are unable to give birth and their calves must be delivered by
Caesarean section. In effect, cattle are
being bred who are unable to reproduce naturally, for the sake of profit.4
Meat cattle may live
outdoors, kept indoors on slatted floors with no bedding, or kept inside during
winter. American style feedlots (which are basically battery farming for dairy
cows) are gradually being brought in to the UK’s system.5 Indoor
cattle may be tethered to prevent them from moving. The calves may be subjected to castration and
dehorning, and calves with too many teats may have the extra ones chopped off
with scissors.6
They will usually be allowed
to live for 1-2 years, of a natural lifespan of 25. Cattle are usually slaughtered by first being
stunned with a captive bolt, then being hung up by a back leg and bled to death
(sometimes cattle are both stunned and killed electrically). Stunning is not always adequate. The animals
may face distress and injury from the inadequate or inappropriate restraints
and pens. There is potentially “very significant pain and distress” from the
slaughter methods.7
1. DEFRA. Cattle and calves; beef and
veal, UK.
http://www.defra.gov.uk/evidence/statistics/foodfarm/general/auk/latest/excel/documents/Table-5-13.xls
(accessed 30th March 2010)
2. RMIF. Introduction to beef
production in the UK.
http://redmeatindustryforum.org.uk/supplychain/BeefProduction.htm
(accessed 30th March 2010)
3. Beyond Calf Exports Forum.
Attitudes to male dairy calves are becoming more black and white. http://www.ciwf.org.uk/includes/documents/cm_docs/2009/c/calf_forum_report.pdf
(accessed 30th March 2010)
4. Uystepruyst C.H. Coghe J. Dorts
T.H. et al. Optimal timing of elective Caesarian section in Belgian White and
Blue breed of cattle: the calf’s point of view. The Veterinary Journal 2002; 163: 267-282
5. The Guardian. Britain’s first
milk factory. http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/wordofmouth/2010/mar/02/milk-production-factory-farming
6. DEFRA. Code of recommendations for
the welfare of livestock: Cattle. http://www.defra.gov.uk/foodfarm/farmanimal/welfare/onfarm/documents/cattcode.pdf
(accessed 30th March 2010)
7. FAWC. Report on the welfare of
farmed animals at slaughter or killing part 1: Red meat animals http://www.fawc.org.uk/reports/pb8347.pdf
p.35 (accessed 30th March 2010)